Harley-Davidson Iron 883 Sportster vs. Honda Shadow Phantom?

Which would be better for a first bike and a long daily commute of 140 miles (1hr 15 min each way). Would the liquid cooled Honda engine provide a more comfortable ride? What about reliability?

Harleys are as reliable as can be.
The engine does not make the ride.
Both will comfortably make the trip on a daily basis if set up to fit you correctly.

I now ride an HD, but I used to commute (2 hours) on an old CB650. I’ve had water cooled, too.

Air vs. water, Honda vs. HD…… long time arguments that have die-hards on both sides.
It’s not wise to totally trust the opinion of anyone that won’t truly consider the other side.

Now, as far as the first bike part goes – I don’t recommend bikes. There is such a large variety, most of which I have not ridden. I do recommend a Basic Rider’s Course before buying a first bike. It gives you an idea of what you may want in a bike.

2005 Harley-Davidson XL 1200C Sportster #RX2934A1 in

Harley-Davidson Sportster Performance Handbook (Motorbooks Workshop) $13.48 Improve your Sporty in every way! From bolting on a carb and pipe to building a 100-cubic-inch monster, this is your ticket to a faster, better-handling Ironhead or Evolution Sportster. This complete guide has been fully updated to reflect the latest aftermarket parts and methods. Packed with expert advice on how to build up your engine for improved horsepower and greater reliability. New chapters…